top of page
Image by Vicky Ng

NYC Bagels

​

A curated list.

​

Few foods are as closely associated with New York City as the bagel. Brought to America by Jewish immigrants from Eastern Europe in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, bagels became a staple of New York's Jewish neighborhoods, particularly on the Lower East Side. Traditionally hand-rolled, boiled, and then baked, the New York bagel became famous for its chewy texture, glossy crust, and unmistakable flavor.

What began as a humble immigrant food grew into one of the city's most beloved culinary traditions. From classic bagels with cream cheese and lox to creative modern combinations, the bagel remains an essential part of New York's food culture.

I've curated a selection of NYC bagel shops worth discovering, from longstanding neighborhood institutions to newer favorites keeping this delicious NYC tradition alive.

Manhattan

MURRAY'S BAGELS

500 Avenue of the Americas, Greenwich Village, Manhattan

​

murraysbagels.com

 

Murray's Bagels has one of Manhattan's most personal Jewish family stories. Founder Adam Pomerantz was working as a vice president at Merrill Lynch when he decided to leave Wall Street and pursue his dream of opening a traditional New York bagel shop. His inspiration came from childhood Thursday dinners, when his father, Murray, would bring home bagels, lox, sable, whitefish, cream cheese, and other Jewish appetizing specialties from the Lower East Side, where he operated a women's clothing business on Rivington Street.

Determined to learn the craft properly, Adam apprenticed at a traditional wholesale bagel bakery in New Jersey, working from 2 a.m. until 11 a.m. He studied bagel-making techniques and experimented with recipes before opening Murray's Bagels in November 1996. He named the shop after his father, honoring the man who introduced him to the Jewish food traditions he loved. The Greenwich Village institution continues to serve traditional New York bagels and appetizing, and its bagels are available for nationwide shipping through Goldbelly.

TRY: The everything bagel with cream cheese and lox, sablefish, whitefish salad, scallion cream cheese, and traditional bagels by the dozen.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. Customers requiring kosher food should inquire directly.

HOLIDAY NOTE: A particularly good choice for traditional Jewish-style breakfasts, family brunches, and smoked fish platters. Nationwide shipping makes it an option for sending a taste of New York to family and friends.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

ZUCKER'S BAGELS & SMOKED FISH

143 Chambers Street, Tribeca, Manhattan

273 Columbus Avenue, Upper West Side, Manhattan

40 East 23rd Street, Flatiron, Manhattan

370 Lexington Avenue, Midtown, Manhattan

242 Eighth Avenue, Chelsea, Manhattan

125 Fulton Street, Financial District, Manhattan

1065 Sixth Avenue, Bryant Park, Manhattan

​

zuckersbagels.com

 

Zucker's Bagels & Smoked Fish is another Manhattan business with a meaningful family connection to New York's Jewish food traditions. Founder Matt Pomerantz, a lifelong New Yorker, named the bakery after his mother, Roslyn, whose maiden name was Zucker. Matt grew up around his family's Lower East Side clothing business and spent his formative years eating in classic New York restaurants and working in Catskills dining establishments.

Founded in the mid-2000s, Zucker's combines traditional hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels with smoked fish, cream cheese spreads, and classic New York appetizing. Matt later partnered with Dan Pace to expand the business across Manhattan. Zucker's also has a significant charitable commitment, providing approximately 100,000 bagel breakfasts annually to The Bowery Mission, along with support for other New York organizations. Its bagels and brunch kits are available for nationwide shipping.

TRY: The everything bagel with Nova smoked salmon, scallion cream cheese, whitefish salad, traditional bagels with lox, and smoked fish brunch kits.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. Customers requiring kosher food should verify the menu and preparation.

HOLIDAY NOTE: A convenient option for Jewish-style holiday brunches, smoked fish platters, bagel assortments, and gifts shipped nationwide. Catering and overnight shipping are available.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

TAL BAGELS

1324 Lexington Avenue, Upper East Side, Manhattan

977 First Avenue, Midtown East, Manhattan

357 First Avenue, Gramercy, Manhattan

​

talbagelsnyc.com

 

An Upper East Side institution since 1988, Tal Bagels has spent nearly four decades serving traditional New York bagels, smoked fish, salads, and homemade spreads. Its first shop opened in a neighborhood with a longstanding Jewish community, where bagels and appetizing have remained an important part of everyday food culture.

Tal Bagels follows the traditional New York method of boiling and baking its bagels, using simple ingredients without chemical preservatives. The bakery emphasizes freshness, preparing new batches throughout the day. Its extensive selection of smoked fish, cream cheese, bialys, and traditional bagel combinations makes it a classic neighborhood destination. For visitors exploring the Upper East Side, Tal offers a taste of the city's enduring Jewish deli and bagel traditions.

TRY: The everything bagel with vegetable cream cheese, sesame bagel with Nova smoked salmon, fresh bialys, whitefish salad, and classic cream cheese spreads.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. Customers requiring kosher food should inquire directly.

HOLIDAY NOTE: A convenient neighborhood option for bagels, smoked fish, spreads, and traditional Jewish-style holiday breakfasts. Contact individual locations for holiday ordering and catering.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels and bialys are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

TOMPKINS SQUARE BAGELS

165 Avenue A, East Village, Manhattan

 

tompkinssquarebagels.com

​

Tompkins Square Bagels opened in 2011 as a neighborhood bakery created by Christopher Pugliese, who learned the art of traditional bagel-making as a teenager at Bake City Bagels in Gravesend, Brooklyn. Working alongside experienced bagel bakers, Pugliese developed a deep appreciation for the craft, particularly the importance of careful preparation and consistency.

His original East Village shop was designed to feel like the neighborhood bagel stores he remembered from Brooklyn. Local artists and craftspeople helped create the space, and the bakery quickly became part of the East Village community. Every bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh, while cream cheese spreads are prepared in-house.

The bakery has since expanded to additional Manhattan locations and offers nationwide shipping through Goldbelly. Its story reflects the passing of traditional New York bagel-making skills from one generation of bakers to another.

TRY: The everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, specialty cream cheese flavors, classic lox combinations, and fresh bagels by the dozen.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. Customers requiring kosher food should verify ingredients and preparation.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Bagel assortments, spreads, and catering options are available for family gatherings. Nationwide shipping offers another way to share New York bagels with friends and relatives.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

POPUP BAGELS

177 Thompson Street, Greenwich Village, Manhattan

1457 Third Avenue, Upper East Side, Manhattan

338 Columbus Avenue, Upper West Side, Manhattan

20 East 16th Street, Union Square, Manhattan

139 East 57th Street, Midtown East, Manhattan

370 Seventh Avenue, Midtown, Manhattan

315 Greenwich Street, Tribeca, Manhattan

1501 Broadway, Times Square, Manhattan

​

popupbagels.com

 

One of the most remarkable recent success stories in New York's bagel scene began in a backyard in Westport, Connecticut, during the COVID-19 pandemic. In 2020, founder Adam Goldberg began experimenting with homemade bagels and sharing them with friends and neighbors. What started as a small pickup operation quickly developed a devoted following, with customers lining up for bags of freshly baked bagels.

Unlike traditional New York bagel shops, PopUp Bagels introduced a different approach. Its smaller bagels are served hot and whole, with a crispy crust and soft interior. Rather than slicing and toasting them, customers are encouraged to follow the company's signature ritual: "Grip, Rip and Dip." Simply tear off a piece of warm bagel and dip it into one of the rotating cream cheese spreads.

The concept became a sensation, winning Best Bagel at Brooklyn BagelFest two consecutive years and attracting investors including actor Paul Rudd, Olympic swimmer Michael Phelps, and former NFL star Michael Strahan. The company opened its first New York City storefront in Greenwich Village in 2023 and has since expanded throughout Manhattan and across the country.

Its rapid growth demonstrates how a traditional food with deep roots in Jewish immigrant culture continues to inspire new businesses and creative approaches more than a century later.

TRY: Fresh hot everything, sesame, plain, and poppy seed bagels with classic scallion cream cheese or one of the rotating specialty schmears. Order a bag of three or a dozen for the full experience.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. Customers following kosher dietary laws should verify ingredients, spreads, and preparation directly with the bakery.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Bagels by the dozen and tubs of cream cheese are convenient for family breakfasts, brunches, and gatherings. Catering and advance ordering are available at participating locations.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional wheat bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified kosher-for-Passover offerings confirmed.

ESS-A-BAGEL

324 First Avenue, Gramercy, Manhattan

831 Third Avenue, Midtown East, Manhattan

108 West 32nd Street, Midtown, Manhattan

​

ess-a-bagel.com

 

A beloved New York bagel institution with deep family roots, Ess-a-Bagel was founded in 1976 by Florence and Gene Wilpon and Florence's brother, Aaron Wenzelberg. The family came from an Austrian baking background, bringing generations of European baking knowledge to Manhattan. Their oversized, hand-rolled bagels quickly attracted attention, and within two years, Ess-a-Bagel had been voted a leading bagel destination in the tri-state area.

The bakery's family story continued after Florence passed away in 2013. Her sister Muriel and niece Melanie took over the business, preserving the traditions that made Ess-a-Bagel famous. When the original First Avenue shop closed in 2015, the family reopened nearby, keeping the institution alive. Today, Ess-a-Bagel remains known for its substantial, chewy bagels, generous cream cheese spreads, smoked fish, and classic New York appetizing selections.

TRY: The everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, sesame bagel with Nova Scotia smoked salmon, whitefish salad, and traditional Jewish bakery specialties including rugelach.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. Customers requiring kosher food should verify ingredients and preparation.

HOLIDAY NOTE: A popular choice for bagel platters, smoked fish, cream cheese assortments, and traditional Jewish-style holiday brunches. Catering is available.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

H&H BAGELS

1551 Second Avenue, Upper East Side, Manhattan

526 Columbus Avenue, Upper West Side, Manhattan

429 Third Avenue, Kips Bay, Manhattan

Moynihan Train Hall, 421 Eighth Avenue, Midtown West, Manhattan

Penn Station, LIRR Concourse, Midtown West, Manhattan

​

hhbagels.com

 

Few names are more closely associated with the New York bagel than H&H Bagels. Established in 1972, the company became an Upper West Side institution and helped introduce traditional New York water bagels to generations of residents and visitors. Its signature preparation involves kettle-boiling the dough before baking, producing the distinctive chewy texture and golden crust that define a classic New York bagel.

H&H also has an unusual place in American popular culture. Its bagels have appeared in television shows and films including Seinfeld, Sex and the City, The Office, and You've Got Mail. One memorable Seinfeld storyline features Kramer returning to work at H&H after a lengthy bagel bakers' strike. The company has since expanded beyond New York, but its history remains closely tied to the Upper West Side and the city's Jewish bagel traditions.

TRY: The classic everything bagel, sesame bagel with cream cheese, Nova Scotia smoked salmon sandwich, and traditional New York bagels by the dozen.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. Some menu offerings contain non-kosher meat combinations.

HOLIDAY NOTE: A convenient choice for classic New York bagel breakfasts, brunch platters, and family gatherings. Contact individual locations for catering and holiday ordering.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

BLACK SEED BAGELS

170 Elizabeth Street, Nolita, Manhattan

176 First Avenue, East Village, Manhattan

1188 Broadway, NoMad, Manhattan

425 West 15th Street, Chelsea Market, Manhattan

225 Liberty Street, Battery Park City, Manhattan

30 Rockefeller Plaza, Midtown, Manhattan

200 Park Avenue, Midtown East, Manhattan

​

blackseedbagels.com

 

Black Seed Bagels began in 2014 with an idea that emerged during informal conversations between friends Noah Bernamoff and Matt Kliegman following Hurricane Sandy. Bernamoff brought experience with Montreal-style Jewish deli food, while Kliegman saw an opportunity to introduce a different kind of bagel shop to Manhattan's Nolita neighborhood.

Their concept combined two important North American Jewish bagel traditions: the larger, chewy New York bagel and the smaller, slightly sweeter Montreal bagel. Executive chef and baker Dianna Daoheung developed a signature recipe using naturally fermented dough, boiling the bagels in honey-sweetened water before baking them in a wood-fired oven. The result is a distinctive bagel with a crisp exterior and a chewy interior.

The bakery is particularly interesting for anyone curious about how Jewish immigrant food traditions evolved differently in New York and Montreal. Black Seed brings those two histories together in a contemporary New York setting.

TRY: The sesame bagel with cream cheese, everything bagel with smoked salmon, traditional bagels with scallion cream cheese, and specialty sandwiches.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. Customers requiring kosher food should verify ingredients and preparation.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Bagel platters, smoked fish combinations, and catering selections are available for gatherings. Contact individual locations for holiday ordering.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

PICK-A-BAGEL

891 Eighth Avenue, Midtown West, Manhattan

 

pickabagelnyc.com

​

A Manhattan bagel institution dating to 1988, Pick-A-Bagel has built its reputation on traditional New York bagels made using the classic hand-rolling and kettle-boiling process. The bakery reflects the neighborhood bagel culture that flourished across Manhattan during the late 20th century, when bagel shops became everyday gathering places for residents, office workers, and visitors.

Pick-A-Bagel continues to emphasize freshly baked bagels made in-house, along with traditional cream cheese spreads, smoked fish, and deli selections. Its Midtown location is particularly convenient for visitors staying near Central Park, Columbus Circle, and the Theater District. The company also offers nationwide shipping through Goldbelly, allowing customers outside New York to enjoy its traditional bagels.

TRY: The everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, sesame bagel with smoked salmon, classic breakfast sandwiches, and bagels by the dozen.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. Customers requiring kosher food should inquire directly.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Bagel platters and assorted spreads are convenient for family breakfasts and holiday gatherings. Nationwide shipping is available for customers outside New York.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional wheat bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

APOLLO BAGELS

242 East 10th Street, East Village, Manhattan

73 Greenwich Avenue, West Village, Manhattan

121 Reade Street, Tribeca, Manhattan

41 John Street, Financial District, Manhattan

19 Waverly Place, Greenwich Village, Manhattan

416 Third Avenue, Kips Bay, Manhattan

224 West 35th Street, Midtown, Manhattan

​

apollobagels.com

 

Apollo Bagels represents a newer chapter in New York City's bagel history. Rather than reproducing the oversized, dense bagels associated with many traditional shops, Apollo has become known for its naturally fermented sourdough bagels, with a crisp exterior, airy interior, and distinctive flavor.

The business emerged from the city's contemporary artisan baking movement, demonstrating how the traditional bagel continues to evolve more than a century after Eastern European Jewish immigrants helped establish it as a New York staple. Apollo's approach combines careful fermentation, fresh baking, and a relatively focused menu built around bagels, spreads, and simple sandwiches.

Its popularity has helped introduce a new generation of New Yorkers and visitors to a different interpretation of the city's most recognizable breakfast food. Although Apollo is a modern bakery rather than a historic Jewish family institution, it offers an interesting comparison with Manhattan's traditional bagel shops.

TRY: The plain bagel with cream cheese, everything bagel, sesame bagel, and smoked salmon with cream cheese, tomato, and onion.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. Customers requiring kosher food should verify ingredients and preparation.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Fresh bagels and simple spreads are convenient for breakfast gatherings. Contact individual locations for holiday hours and catering availability.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional sourdough wheat bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

KOSSAR'S BAGELS & BIALYS

367 Grand Street, Lower East Side, Manhattan

1409 York Avenue, Upper East Side, Manhattan

270 West 72nd Street, Upper West Side, Manhattan

536 West 30th Street, Hudson Yards, Manhattan

​

kossars.com

​

One of the most important surviving pieces of New York City's Jewish culinary history, Kossar's dates to 1936 and is recognized as the oldest operating bialy bakery in the United States. It was founded by Isadore Mirsky and Morris Kossar, who brought the baking traditions of Eastern European Jewish immigrants to the Lower East Side. The bialy itself originated in Białystok, Poland, a city with a once-thriving Jewish community that was devastated during the Holocaust.

The bakery has an extraordinary history. In 1958, following a labor dispute, an unexplained explosion destroyed its Clinton Street location. Fortunately, nobody was injured. Kossar's reopened at 367 Grand Street in 1960, where it continues today. Its traditional bialys are baked rather than boiled, with a distinctive depression in the center filled with onions or other ingredients. Alongside them, Kossar's produces classic kettle-boiled New York bagels. This is more than a bakery. It is a surviving connection to the Jewish immigrant neighborhoods that helped shape New York City.

TRY: The traditional onion bialy, everything bagel, sesame bagel, garlic bialy, and classic smoked salmon with cream cheese.

KOSHER NOTE: Current kosher certification has not been confirmed. Customers requiring kosher food should inquire directly.

HOLIDAY NOTE: An especially meaningful destination for Jewish holiday breakfasts, family gatherings, and anyone interested in preserving Eastern European Jewish food traditions. Contact the bakery for holiday ordering and catering.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels and bialys are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

Try a Bagel Baking Class with Award-Winning Baker, Upper West Side, Manhattan

 

Learn new culinary skills during a fun, hands-on bagel-making class led by an award-winning baker. Discover tips and tricks for making a perfect New York–style bagel, and sit down to eat your creations.

​

​

​

Brooklyn

BERGEN BAGELS

473 Bergen Street, Prospect Heights, Brooklyn

536 Myrtle Avenue, Clinton Hill, Brooklyn

949 Fulton Street, Clinton Hill, Brooklyn

​

bergenbagels.com

 

One of Brooklyn's most interesting Israeli-American bagel stories begins with founder Yitzhak Saadi, who grew up in Israel and worked as a cook on a kibbutz before moving permanently to the United States. After meeting his future wife in Brooklyn, Saadi helped friends and relatives operate several businesses before a friend encouraged him to enter the bagel industry.

He opened Bergen Bagels in 1999, eventually expanding to three Brooklyn locations. The business combines Israeli entrepreneurial roots with the traditional New York bagel culture that developed in the city's Jewish neighborhoods. Its bagels are made fresh throughout the day, and the shops prepare their own cream cheese spreads, muffins, and other baked goods.

Saadi's journey from cooking on an Israeli kibbutz to establishing a successful Brooklyn food business is exactly the kind of personal story that makes New York's food culture so interesting. Bergen Bagels remains a neighborhood favorite, with an extensive selection of spreads ranging from traditional scallion cream cheese to olive, walnut raisin, and sun-dried tomato.

TRY: The everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, lox bagel, walnut raisin cream cheese, sun-dried tomato cream cheese, and traditional black-and-white cookies.

KOSHER NOTE: Current kosher certification has not been confirmed. Customers requiring kosher food should verify ingredients and preparation.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Fresh bagels, spreads, and breakfast platters are convenient for Jewish holiday brunches and family gatherings. Contact the bakery for catering and advance ordering.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional wheat bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

KOSHER BAGEL HOLE

1431 Coney Island Avenue, Midwood, Brooklyn

1423 Avenue J, Midwood, Brooklyn

​

kosherbagelhole.com

 

A family-run Brooklyn institution since 1985, Kosher Bagel Hole has served generations of residents in one of New York City's most established Orthodox Jewish neighborhoods. Its locations on Coney Island Avenue and Avenue J place it in the heart of a community where kosher bakeries, Jewish schools, synagogues, and traditional food shops remain central to everyday life.

Unlike many contemporary bagel shops that emphasize oversized sandwiches and elaborate toppings, Kosher Bagel Hole maintains a more traditional approach. Its bagels are complemented by fresh vegetable salads, smoked fish, cheese products, and dairy breakfast selections.

The bakery's longevity is especially meaningful in a neighborhood where Jewish food traditions are closely connected to family life, Shabbat preparations, and religious celebrations. For visitors interested in experiencing Brooklyn's living Jewish food culture rather than simply visiting a famous tourist destination, this is a particularly worthwhile stop.

TRY: The everything bagel with cream cheese, traditional sesame bagel, smoked fish sandwiches, fresh vegetable salads, and bagels by the dozen.

KOSHER NOTE: The business operates as a kosher bagel shop. Kashrut listings identify Kehilah Kashrus supervision for its Midwood locations. Customers requiring a particular certification standard should confirm the current certificate at the shop.

HOLIDAY NOTE: The bakery offers dairy catering for personal celebrations, corporate gatherings, and community events. Contact the shop for Shabbat and Jewish holiday ordering, including closing times before religious holidays.

PASSOVER NOTE: Regular bagels are not kosher for Passover. Confirm directly whether any separately certified Passover products or catering options are available.

BAGEL HOLE

400 Seventh Avenue, Park Slope, Brooklyn

​

Bagel Hole is one of Brooklyn's most distinctive old-school bagel institutions. Operating since 1985, the tiny Park Slope bakery has built a devoted following by refusing to abandon the traditional style of New York bagels.

Its bagels are noticeably smaller, denser, and chewier than the oversized versions common in many modern bagel shops. The bakery focuses on the bagel itself rather than elaborate sandwiches or dozens of toppings. One of its most famous policies is that it does not toast bagels. The philosophy is simple: a properly made, freshly baked bagel should not need to be toasted.

Another unusual detail is the shop's longstanding no-photography policy, which adds to its reputation as a place more interested in baking than publicity.

Bagel Hole represents a style of bagel that was once more common throughout New York's Jewish neighborhoods. For anyone interested in understanding what a traditional New York bagel tasted like before bagels became larger and softer, this is an important stop.

TRY: A fresh plain bagel, sesame bagel, everything bagel, or poppy seed bagel with traditional cream cheese. The bagels are best enjoyed fresh.

KOSHER NOTE: Current kosher certification has not been confirmed. This is a separate business from Kosher Bagel Hole in Midwood.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Fresh bagels by the dozen are suitable for family breakfasts and gatherings. Contact the bakery regarding advance ordering and holiday hours.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional wheat bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

images (40).jpeg

CAPUTO BAGELS

81 Fifth Avenue, Park Slope, Brooklyn

 

caputobagels.com

​

One of Brooklyn's newest bagel shops has one of its oldest family baking stories. Caputo Bagels opened on October 5, 2026, bringing together fifth-generation Brooklyn baker James Caputo and Israeli restaurateur Rafael "Rafi" Hasid, the owner of Miriam, a popular Israeli restaurant in Park Slope.

The Caputo family's Brooklyn baking history dates to the early 1900s, when Sicilian immigrant Giovanni Caputo established the family's bakery. For more than a century, Caputo's Bake Shop served Carroll Gardens, becoming a neighborhood institution known for its Italian breads and traditional baked goods.

When the original bakery closed in April 2026 after more than 120 years, it marked the end of an extraordinary chapter in Brooklyn's food history. But James Caputo was not finished baking.

He partnered with longtime friend Rafi Hasid to create a new bagel business that would combine generations of Italian baking knowledge with a food deeply rooted in Jewish culinary tradition.

The bakery uses a decades-old sourdough starter and traditional hand-rolling techniques to produce bagels with a crisp, deeply browned crust and lighter interior. Its menu includes classic cream cheese spreads, smoked fish, and creative specialties.

This is a particularly interesting addition to Jewish Food NYC because it brings together an Israeli restaurateur and a fifth-generation Brooklyn baker, demonstrating how the city's immigrant food traditions continue to influence one another.

TRY: The hand-rolled sourdough sesame bagel, everything bagel with cream cheese, smoked salmon bagel, and fresh pastries. The bakery also offers a distinctive lard and provolone bagel inspired by the Caputo family's Italian baking traditions.

KOSHER NOTE: Not kosher certified. The menu includes pork-derived ingredients, including lard, and is not suitable for customers requiring kosher preparation.

HOLIDAY NOTE: A new destination for bagel breakfasts, family brunches, and neighborhood gatherings. Contact the bakery regarding holiday hours and special ordering.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional sourdough wheat bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

BAGEL PUB

287 Ninth Street, Park Slope, Brooklyn

57 Seventh Avenue, Park Slope, Brooklyn

775 Franklin Avenue, Crown Heights, Brooklyn

313 36th Street, Sunset Park, Brooklyn

​

bagelpub.com

 

Bagel Pub began in Park Slope in 2012 with a concept that combined traditional New York bagel-making with the atmosphere of a welcoming neighborhood café. Its original Ninth Street location introduced customers to hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels baked fresh daily, along with an extensive selection of cream cheese spreads and breakfast sandwiches.

The business expanded across Brooklyn before opening additional locations in Manhattan. Despite its growth, Bagel Pub continues to emphasize the neighborhood gathering-place atmosphere that inspired its name. The idea is that a bagel shop can serve the same social purpose as a local pub, bringing together residents, friends, families, and regular customers.

Its Crown Heights location is particularly interesting for visitors exploring one of Brooklyn's most historically significant Jewish neighborhoods. Crown Heights is home to the worldwide headquarters of the Chabad-Lubavitch movement and a large Orthodox Jewish community. While Bagel Pub is not presented as a kosher establishment, its location offers visitors an opportunity to explore the neighborhood's broader Jewish history and culture.

TRY: The everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, sesame bagel with smoked salmon, specialty cream cheese spreads, and generously filled breakfast sandwiches.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. The menu includes non-kosher meat combinations.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Bagel platters, assorted spreads, and catering selections are available for family breakfasts, celebrations, and group gatherings. Contact individual locations for holiday ordering.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

258s.jpg

HOLESOME BAGELS

333A Kingston Avenue, Crown Heights, Brooklyn

 

holesomebagels.com

​

In 1989, two friends from Israel, Arele Sheinberger and Jacob Baitch, arrived in New York and noticed something surprising about Crown Heights, one of the city's most important Jewish neighborhoods. Despite its thriving Jewish community, they believed the neighborhood lacked a proper New York bagel shop.

They opened Crown Bagels, beginning a business that would eventually become Holesome Bagels. More than three decades later, the shop remains a fixture on Kingston Avenue, just steps from the neighborhood's famous Chabad-Lubavitch institutions.

One of the shop's most unusual specialties is its potato bagel, a bagel filled with seasoned hash brown potatoes. The creation became a signature item, with hundreds of thousands sold over the years. It is a particularly interesting combination of traditional New York bagel culture and the comforting potato dishes long associated with Eastern European Jewish cooking.

Today, the business is led by second-generation family member Menachem Sheinberger. What began as a neighborhood bagel shop has expanded into a kosher dairy restaurant and catering business serving local families, celebrations, and community gatherings.

Holesome Bagels is a wonderful example of Israeli immigrants building a business that has become part of everyday Jewish life in Brooklyn.

TRY: The signature potato bagel, especially the everything bagel filled with seasoned potatoes. Also try classic bagels with cream cheese, dairy breakfast dishes, and freshly prepared salads.

KOSHER NOTE: Kosher dairy under the Vaad Hakashrus of Crown Heights (CHK), with Cholov Yisroel and Pas Yisroel standards reported. Confirm the current certificate for specific requirements.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Offers kosher dairy catering for family celebrations, community events, and gatherings. The shop closes for Shabbat, so check Friday hours and holiday schedules before visiting.

PASSOVER NOTE: Regular wheat bagels are not kosher for Passover. Contact the restaurant to confirm whether any separately certified Passover catering or menu items are available.

images (2).png

SCHICK'S BAKERY

Originally established in Borough Park, Brooklyn

Historic Jewish bakery and kosher baked-goods brand

​

schicksbakery.com

 

Schick's Bakery has one of Brooklyn's most meaningful stories of Jewish family resilience, Holocaust survival, and the preservation of traditional kosher baking.

The bakery was established in the early 1940s by Renee Schick, a rabbi's widow raising young children. To support her family, she began baking traditional Jewish desserts, reportedly rising as early as 3 a.m. to prepare the cakes and pastries that would become the foundation of her business.

In 1960, the bakery entered a remarkable new chapter when two brothers-in-law, Moshe Braunfeld and Chaim Widawsky, purchased the business.

Both men were Holocaust survivors.

Having survived the destruction of European Jewish life during World War II, they became the owners of a bakery devoted to preserving the very culinary traditions that Nazi persecution had threatened to erase.

Under their families' stewardship, Schick's became especially well known for its kosher-for-Passover baked goods, including cakes, cookies, and pastries made without ordinary wheat flour or other prohibited Passover ingredients.

The bakery developed a national following, supplying kosher supermarkets, hotel programs, and retailers with products that allowed families observing Passover to enjoy traditional desserts.

The Braunfeld and Widawsky families continued operating the business for decades before selling it to new investors in 2011.

Although its original Borough Park storefront is no longer a current destination, the Schick's name and product tradition continue through the brand's website.

Schick's is a powerful reminder that Jewish food businesses often represent far more than commercial success. For Holocaust survivors and their descendants, rebuilding a bakery in America could also mean preserving family traditions, religious observance, and a connection to a European Jewish world that had been devastated.

HISTORIC SPECIALTIES: Kosher-for-Passover cakes, macaroons, brownies, honey cakes, seven-layer cake, and traditional Eastern European Jewish pastries.

KOSHER NOTE: Schick's specializes in kosher baked goods. Check the current certification on individual products.

HOLIDAY NOTE: The brand has historically been especially associated with Passover desserts and other traditional Jewish holiday baked goods.

PASSOVER NOTE: Schick's is particularly known for kosher-for-Passover pastries, including non-gebrokts products. Verify the current Passover certification and labeling before purchasing.

images (42).jpeg

WILLIAMSBURG HEIMISHE BAKERY BY ONEG

188 Lee Avenue, South Williamsburg, Brooklyn

​

onegbakery.com

 

Behind one of New York City's most celebrated chocolate babkas is an extraordinary story of Holocaust survival, Jewish family traditions, and recipes preserved across generations.

The bakery's roots trace to two Hungarian Jewish sisters who survived World War II and emigrated to Brooklyn. They brought cherished family recipes for challah, babka, rugelach, and hamantaschen, along with the hope of one day opening a bakery where these traditional foods could be shared with their new community.

With encouragement from their children and grandchildren, the sisters eventually opened Oneg Bakery in Williamsburg during the 1980s. Their recipes became part of the neighborhood's Jewish food culture, and the business developed a devoted following far beyond Brooklyn's Hasidic community.

Today, the family continues the tradition under the name Williamsburg Heimishe Bakery by Oneg. Its signature chocolate babka is particularly famous for its extraordinary density, generous layers of rich chocolate, and slightly crisp exterior. Unlike the lighter, bread-like babkas found elsewhere, Oneg's version is intensely chocolatey and traditionally sold by weight.

The bakery has received recognition from New York food writers, including praise for producing some of the city's most distinctive chocolate babka. It is also a reminder of the importance of preserving Jewish family recipes, especially those carried to America by people who survived the destruction of European Jewish communities during the Holocaust.

For visitors exploring South Williamsburg, this modest neighborhood bakery offers something far more meaningful than a sweet treat. It is a living connection to Hungarian Jewish culinary heritage, preserved by the descendants of women who rebuilt their lives in Brooklyn.

TRY: The famous double-chocolate babka, sold by weight, along with traditional challah, chocolate rugelach, cinnamon pastries, and hamantaschen.

KOSHER NOTE: The bakery identifies itself as kosher certified under the Central Rabbinical Congress (CRC). Check the current certificate for specific requirements.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Fresh challah is a favorite for Shabbat, while traditional pastries and hamantaschen are associated with Jewish holidays. The bakery closes on Saturdays and typically closes early on Fridays. Check holiday schedules before visiting.

PASSOVER NOTE: Regular babka, challah, rugelach, and hamantaschen made with wheat flour are not kosher for Passover. Confirm directly whether any separately certified Passover products are available.

VISITING NOTE: The bakery's official website lists its Brooklyn location from September onward and a seasonal Monticello, New York, location during July and August. Check the current location before making a special trip.

SHELSKY'S OF BROOKLYN

141 Court Street, Cobble Hill, Brooklyn

453 Fourth Avenue, Gowanus, Brooklyn

​

shelskys.com

 

Shelsky's is one of Brooklyn's most compelling modern Jewish food stories. Founder Peter Shelsky grew up in New York eating Kossar's bialys and hand-sliced Nova smoked salmon from Zabar's, developing a deep appreciation for the Eastern European Jewish food traditions that shaped the city.

After working in celebrated New York kitchens, including Eleven Madison Park and Café Sabarsky, Shelsky set out to create his own interpretation of the traditional Jewish appetizing shop. He opened Shelsky's of Brooklyn in 2011, combining classic smoked fish, bagels, bialys, and Jewish comfort foods with the techniques and creativity of a professionally trained chef.

The business eventually expanded with a dedicated bagel bakery on Fourth Avenue. Its bagels are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh, while its smoked fish selection reflects the traditions of historic New York appetizing institutions.

One particularly interesting detail is Shelsky's willingness to experiment. Alongside classic sesame and everything bagels, the bakery has offered Sichuan peppercorn bagels and unusual cream cheese flavors. The result is a business that honors Jewish culinary heritage without treating it as something that cannot evolve.

Shelsky's also ships nationwide, making it possible to send traditional New York bagels, smoked fish, and Jewish food specialties across the country.

TRY: The Member of the Tribe sandwich with Nova smoked salmon and scallion cream cheese, pastrami-smoked salmon, traditional onion bialys, Sichuan peppercorn bagels, and whitefish salad.

KOSHER NOTE: Not kosher certified. Some menu items contain pork and other non-kosher ingredients. Customers observing kosher dietary laws should not assume that traditional Jewish dishes are kosher.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Shelsky's offers catering for brit milah celebrations, bar and bat mitzvahs, baby namings, shiva gatherings, and holiday entertaining. Smoked fish platters, bagel assortments, and nationwide gift packages are available.

PASSOVER NOTE: Regular bagels and bialys are not kosher for Passover. Any Passover-specific products should be checked individually for appropriate certification.

HIGHWAY BAGELS

1923 Kings Highway, Midwood, Brooklyn

​

highwaybagels.com

 

Highway Bagels is one of Brooklyn's oldest surviving bagel businesses, with a history dating to 1951. Located on Kings Highway in Midwood, the bakery began as a wholesale operation supplying bagels to other stores and food businesses throughout the New York area.

That wholesale history is an important part of the New York bagel story. Long before bagel shops became fashionable breakfast destinations, wholesale bakeries produced large quantities of bagels for neighborhood groceries, appetizing shops, and restaurants. Highway Bagels was part of that tradition.

Current owners Alberto and Luigi have emphasized the importance of preserving the bakery's original methods rather than changing the formula that established its reputation. Over the decades, the business evolved from a wholesale bakery into a full neighborhood bagel shop offering sandwiches, spreads, and catering.

Its continued operation in Midwood provides a connection to the postwar period when Brooklyn's Jewish neighborhoods were major centers of traditional bagel production.

TRY: Fresh plain, sesame, and everything bagels, cream cheese spreads, lox sandwiches, and traditional breakfast combinations.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. Customers requiring kosher food should inquire directly.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Catering and bagel assortments are available for family gatherings and special occasions. Contact the bakery for holiday ordering and hours.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional wheat bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

FRANKEL'S DELICATESSEN & APPETIZING

631 Manhattan Avenue, Greenpoint, Brooklyn

​

frankelsdelicatessen.com

 

Frankel's is a modern Brooklyn Jewish deli built around a deeply personal family story. Brothers Zach and Alex Frankel grew up on Manhattan's Upper West Side, surrounded by the classic Jewish appetizing traditions of institutions such as Barney Greengrass and Russ & Daughters.

In 2016, the brothers opened Frankel's in Greenpoint to recreate the food and atmosphere they remembered from childhood. The shop was designed as a tribute to the old-fashioned Jewish delicatessen, complete with traditional signage, family photographs, smoked fish, bagels, bialys, and classic Jewish comfort foods.

Family recipes play an important role in the business. The brothers incorporated their grandmother's brisket recipe into the menu, connecting the restaurant directly to their own Jewish family history.

Frankel's also has an unusual connection to the New York music scene. Alex Frankel is a member of the electronic music duo Holy Ghost!, and musicians El-P and Despot were among the early investors. The result is a Jewish deli with both old-world culinary roots and contemporary Brooklyn creative connections.

Although Frankel's is more of an appetizing shop and delicatessen than a dedicated bagel bakery, its bagel sandwiches and smoked fish make it an excellent addition to a Brooklyn bagel guide.

TRY: The pastrami-smoked salmon bagel with scallion cream cheese and dill cucumbers, Nova smoked salmon with cream cheese, whitefish salad, and traditional bialys.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. The menu includes meat and dairy offerings, so customers observing kosher dietary laws should verify ingredients and preparation.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Traditional Jewish deli specialties, smoked fish, and bagel sandwiches make Frankel's a worthwhile destination for holiday meals and family gatherings. Contact the restaurant regarding catering and special holiday offerings.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels and bialys are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

OLDE BROOKLYN BAGEL SHOPPE

645 Vanderbilt Avenue, Prospect Heights, Brooklyn

 

oldebrooklynbagelshop.com

​

A Prospect Heights neighborhood institution since 2010, Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe has built its reputation around traditional New York bagel-making and a willingness to introduce new flavors. Every bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh on the premises each morning, preserving the techniques that made New York bagels famous.

One of the bakery's most interesting creations is its signature za'atar bagel. Za'atar, a Middle Eastern seasoning blend commonly made with herbs, sesame seeds, and sumac, brings a distinctive regional flavor to the traditional New York bagel. The shop also offers za'atar cream cheese, combining a familiar New York breakfast staple with ingredients widely used in Israeli and other Middle Eastern cuisines.

The bakery has developed a loyal neighborhood following for its more than 30 cream cheese flavors and substantial breakfast sandwiches. Its combination of traditional preparation and creative flavors reflects the changing culinary character of Brooklyn.

TRY: The signature za'atar bagel with za'atar cream cheese, everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, smoked salmon with cream cheese and capers, and pastrami lox with truffle cream cheese.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. The menu includes non-kosher meat combinations, and customers requiring kosher food should verify ingredients and preparation.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Bagels by the dozen, assorted spreads, and breakfast sandwiches are available for family gatherings and special occasions. Contact the bakery regarding holiday ordering.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional wheat bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

BAGEL JOINT

230 Calyer Street, Greenpoint, Brooklyn

 

bagel-joint.com

​

Bagel Joint is a newer addition to Brooklyn's Jewish food scene, bringing a creative, internationally influenced approach to traditional Jewish baked goods. Located in Greenpoint, the bakery and appetizing shop celebrates bagels, bialys, and the wider culinary traditions associated with Jewish baking.

Rather than treating the bagel as a food that must remain unchanged, Bagel Joint uses it as a starting point for exploring flavors from different culinary cultures. Its concept reflects an important part of Jewish food history: Jewish communities have lived across Europe, the Middle East, North Africa, and beyond, adapting local ingredients and cooking traditions while maintaining their own distinctive food cultures.

The bakery's approach makes it an interesting contrast to Brooklyn's longstanding bagel institutions. Visitors can experience familiar Jewish baked goods presented through a contemporary culinary perspective, while exploring one of Brooklyn's most dynamic food neighborhoods.

TRY: Freshly baked bagels, traditional bialys, specialty cream cheese spreads, and seasonal sandwiches. Ask about rotating flavors and current specialties.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. Customers requiring kosher food should verify ingredients and preparation directly.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Contact the bakery regarding holiday schedules, advance ordering, and any seasonal Jewish baked goods.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional wheat bagels and bialys are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

RUSS & DAUGHTERS BROOKLYN

141 Flushing Avenue, Building 77, Brooklyn Navy Yard, Brooklyn

​

russanddaughters.com

 

One of New York's most celebrated Jewish food businesses began with a Polish Jewish immigrant selling herring from a pushcart on the Lower East Side. Joel Russ arrived from Strzyżów, Poland, in the early 1900s and eventually opened an appetizing shop in 1914.

In 1933, he made an extraordinary decision for the time. He renamed the business Russ & Daughters in honor of his three daughters, Hattie, Ida, and Anne, recognizing their importance to the family enterprise. It is regarded as the first known American business to use "& Daughters" in its name.

More than a century later, the business remains in the Russ family, now operated by fourth-generation cousins Niki Russ Federman and Josh Russ Tupper.

In 2019, Russ & Daughters opened an 18,000-square-foot Brooklyn location inside the historic Brooklyn Navy Yard. The former naval supply depot became a working Jewish bakery, appetizing shop, production kitchen, and nationwide shipping center.

Unlike the original Lower East Side shop, the Brooklyn location allows visitors to watch bakers preparing traditional Jewish baked goods through a glass window. Bagels, bialys, challah, babka, rye bread, pumpernickel, knishes, and black-and-white cookies are all part of the bakery's production.

The Brooklyn Navy Yard location is particularly special because it connects four generations of Jewish immigrant entrepreneurship with the future of traditional New York Jewish food. Visitors can enjoy a freshly prepared bagel and smoked salmon while watching the baking traditions that have helped define the city's culinary identity.

TRY: The classic everything bagel with smoked salmon, cream cheese, tomato, onion, and capers. Also try hand-made bialys, whitefish salad, pastrami-cured salmon, babka, and traditional Jewish baked goods.

KOSHER NOTE: Russ & Daughters is not kosher certified. Its traditional Jewish food offerings should not be confused with kosher supervision.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Offers Jewish holiday specialties, catering platters, and nationwide shipping. Check the website for Rosh Hashanah, Hanukkah, and other seasonal menus.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels, bialys, and regular wheat baked goods are not kosher for Passover. Any special Passover products should be checked individually for certification.

images (41).jpeg

BAGELS BY BELL / BELL'S BROOKLYN BAGELS

Originally established in Borough Park, Brooklyn, in 1947

Current company address: 3333 Royal Avenue, Oceanside, Long Island, NY 11572

​

bialy.com

 

In 1947, Marty and Dotty Bell began making traditional bialys in Borough Park, Brooklyn, establishing a family business that would eventually become one of America's leading producers of this distinctive Jewish baked good.

The family's early bakery operated on 13th Avenue, where Marty worked in a basement equipped with long baking ovens. He used a wooden peel approximately ten feet long to move the bialys in and out of the ovens, preserving the techniques associated with traditional Eastern European baking.

The bialy originated in Białystok, Poland, where it was a specialty of the city's Jewish community. Unlike a bagel, a bialy is not boiled before baking and typically features a shallow indentation filled with onions.

Marty's son Warren Bell eventually took over the family business and expanded production, moving operations to Canarsie, Brooklyn. By 2016, the company was producing approximately 24,000 bialys a day, demonstrating how a small family bakery had grown into a major supplier.

Today, Warren and his son Jared Bell continue the family enterprise, representing three generations of Brooklyn baking history.

The company has expanded beyond traditional bialys to produce New York-style bagels and frozen products distributed through supermarkets and restaurants.

Its products have traveled far beyond Brooklyn, but the company's origins remain firmly rooted in the Jewish baking traditions of Borough Park.

TRY: Bell's traditional onion bialys and Brooklyn-style bagels, available through participating supermarkets and food retailers.

KOSHER NOTE: Check the certification symbol on the specific product package. Certification may vary by product.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Packaged bagels and bialys can be purchased for family breakfasts, gatherings, and holiday entertaining. Check local retailers for availability.

PASSOVER NOTE: Regular bagels and bialys are not kosher for Passover. Purchase only products specifically marked and certified kosher for Passover.

CONEY ISLAND BIALYS AND BAGELS

Historic address: 2359 Coney Island Avenue, Brooklyn

STATUS: CLOSED. Historic Jewish bakery founded in 1920.

Although closed - a story worth sharing!
 

One of Brooklyn's most extraordinary Jewish food stories began in 1920, when Morris Rosenzweig, a Jewish immigrant from Białystok, Poland, established a bakery devoted to bagels and bialys.

Białystok was famous for its bialys, the round, chewy rolls with a shallow center traditionally filled with onions. Jewish immigrants brought this specialty to New York, where it became an essential part of the city's Jewish food culture.

For more than 90 years, Coney Island Bialys and Bagels helped preserve that tradition in Brooklyn. Its longevity connected generations of New Yorkers to a food that originated in the Jewish communities of Eastern Europe, many of which were later devastated during the Holocaust.

In 2011, the bakery faced closure because of financial difficulties and changing neighborhood demographics. Then something remarkable happened.

Two Pakistani-born Muslim businessmen, Zafaryab Ali and Peerzad Shah, stepped forward to save it. Ali had previously worked at the bakery and knew its products and traditions. Together, they took over the business, retaining its original recipes and intending to continue its kosher offerings.

Their decision attracted international attention. At a time when religious and cultural differences often dominate headlines, two Muslim entrepreneurs had chosen to preserve a historic Jewish bakery.

The revival was ultimately temporary, and the bakery had closed by 2016. Nevertheless, its story remains an extraordinary example of New York's immigrant communities preserving one another's culinary traditions.

​

Queens

UTOPIA BAGELS

19-09 Utopia Parkway, Whitestone, Queens

​

utopiabagelsny.com

 

A Queens institution since 1981, Utopia Bagels has earned a reputation as one of New York City's great bagel destinations. Its traditional hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels are baked in a vintage carousel oven dating to 1947, making the oven itself older than the bakery. This unusual piece of equipment is part of what makes Utopia special. The bagels emerge with a beautifully browned crust and chewy interior. What began as a neighborhood favorite has expanded into Manhattan and Long Island City, but the original Whitestone location remains a destination for bagel lovers.

TRY: The everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, sesame bagel with lox, and classic bagel breakfast sandwiches.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. Customers requiring kosher food should inquire directly.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Bagel platters, smoked fish, and cream cheese spreads are excellent choices for family gatherings and holiday brunches.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional wheat bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover bagel offerings confirmed.

BROOKLYN BAGEL & COFFEE COMPANY

35-05 Broadway, Astoria, Queens

​

brooklynbagelny.com

 

Despite its name, Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company began in Astoria, Queens, in 2002. The company has become a favorite for its generously sized New York bagels and extensive selection of cream cheese spreads. Its approach combines traditional bagel-making with creative flavors and modern café culture. The original Astoria location helped establish the brand's reputation before it expanded to other New York neighborhoods.

TRY: The everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, French toast bagel, smoked salmon sandwiches, and specialty cream cheese spreads.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. Customers following kosher dietary laws should verify ingredients and preparation.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Bagel assortments and cream cheese spreads make convenient additions to holiday breakfasts and brunches.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover menu confirmed.

HOWARD BEACH BAGEL CAFE

162-54 Cross Bay Boulevard, Howard Beach, Queens, NY 11414

 

hbbagelcafe.com

 

Established in 1986, Howard Beach Bagel Cafe has been part of the Queens bagel tradition for nearly four decades. The bakery emphasizes traditional preparation, with individually hand-rolled bagels that are kettle-boiled and baked in stone-deck ovens. This method helps create the characteristic New York combination of a firm crust and chewy interior. The shop is a neighborhood destination for bagels, breakfast sandwiches, and classic deli favorites.

TRY: The everything bagel with cream cheese, sesame bagel with smoked salmon, and traditional breakfast sandwiches.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. Customers requiring kosher food should verify ingredients and preparation.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Bagels, spreads, and breakfast platters are convenient for family gatherings. Contact the café regarding holiday ordering.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover menu confirmed.

unnamed (5).webp

WHITESTONE BAGEL FACTORY

24-17 149th Street, Whitestone, Queens

​

whitestonebagelfactory.com

 

Established in 1997, Whitestone Bagel Factory is a neighborhood bakery that continues the old-fashioned New York tradition of hand-rolling, boiling, and baking bagels. Its preparation process is a reminder that the distinctive New York bagel depends on more than a recipe. The dough is shaped by hand, boiled in water, and then baked to develop the characteristic chewy interior and golden crust. Nearly three decades after opening, it remains a local favorite in Whitestone.

TRY: The everything bagel, sesame bagel with cream cheese, and classic breakfast sandwiches.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Fresh bagels and cream cheese assortments are convenient for family breakfasts and holiday gatherings. Contact the bakery for advance ordering.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional wheat bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

MAIN STREET BAGELS

72-26 Main Street, Flushing, Queens

​

mainstreetbagelsny.com

​

This Queens bagel shop has a family history reaching back more than a century. According to the bakery's history, the family's bagel-making tradition began in 1901 when Anshel, an immigrant from Austria, arrived in New York and established bakeries in the region. Later generations continued the tradition, including the opening of Flatlands Bagels in Brooklyn in 1964. The family's baking heritage eventually reached Queens through Jerusalem Bagel Bakery and Main Street Bagels. Today, the shop continues its commitment to traditional methods, freshly baked bagels, and neighborhood hospitality.

TRY: Freshly baked plain, sesame, and everything bagels with cream cheese, along with classic breakfast selections.

KOSHER NOTE: Current kosher certification should be confirmed directly with the bakery. The shop closes on Saturdays.

HOLIDAY NOTE: A particularly interesting destination for those who appreciate the history of Jewish bagel-making. Contact the bakery for holiday ordering and availability.

PASSOVER NOTE: No certified kosher-for-Passover bagel offerings confirmed.

images (43).jpeg

BAGEL OASIS

183-12 Horace Harding Expressway, Fresh Meadows, Queens

​

Bagel Oasis has been serving Queens since 1961, making it one of the borough's longstanding bagel institutions. Known for its traditional New York bagels, the bakery has maintained a loyal following for generations. Its bagels are baked with a distinctive crust and lighter interior, offering a different experience from the oversized, doughier bagels found elsewhere in the city. The shop also offers bialys and homemade cream cheese spreads.

TRY: The egg everything bagel, sesame bagel with cream cheese, fresh bialys, and classic lox combinations.

KOSHER NOTE: Current kosher certification has not been confirmed.

HOLIDAY NOTE: A convenient neighborhood destination for bagels, bialys, and spreads for family breakfasts and gatherings.

PASSOVER NOTE: Regular bagels and bialys are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover products confirmed.

MIDDLE VILLAGE BAGELS

79-16 Eliot Avenue, Middle Village, Queens

​

A neighborhood favorite with a loyal Queens following, Middle Village Bagels received recognition in 2024 when it won the Queens Chamber of Commerce's inaugural borough-wide bagel competition. The shop represents the traditional neighborhood bagel experience, serving freshly made bagels, spreads, coffee, and breakfast sandwiches. Its reputation is built around the everyday New York ritual of stopping for a fresh bagel and coffee.

TRY: The everything bagel with cream cheese, sesame bagel, and classic breakfast sandwiches.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Bagels and spreads are convenient for family breakfasts, weekend gatherings, and holiday entertaining.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

Forest_Hills_Bagels_1___________.jpg

FOREST HILLS BAGEL

104-41 Queens Boulevard, Forest Hills, Queens, NY 11375​

​

fhbagels.com

 

Family-owned and operating since 1998, Forest Hills Bagel specializes in traditional hand-rolled, water-boiled New York bagels. Located in a Queens neighborhood with a rich Jewish history, the bakery is part of the everyday food culture that continues to connect generations of New Yorkers to this classic Jewish culinary tradition. Its emphasis on traditional preparation makes it a worthwhile stop for visitors exploring Forest Hills beyond Manhattan.

TRY: The everything bagel, sesame bagel with cream cheese, and classic lox combinations.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Fresh bagels and assorted spreads are suitable for family breakfasts and holiday brunches. Confirm special ordering directly.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional wheat bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

The Bronx

store-front.jpg

EMPIRE BAGELS

3101 Westchester Avenue, Pelham Bay, Bronx

​

A longtime neighborhood favorite, Empire Bagels is known for its traditional New York bagels served fresh from a walk-up counter. The family-owned business traces its beginnings to 1994 and has built a following among Bronx residents who appreciate its straightforward approach. This is a classic early-morning bagel stop rather than a sit-down café, with customers arriving for hot bagels and breakfast favorites before the day's supply sells out.

TRY: The everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, sesame bagel, and fresh bagels by the dozen.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified.

HOLIDAY NOTE: A convenient option for early-morning bagel pickups and family breakfast gatherings. Special holiday ordering should be confirmed directly.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional wheat bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover products confirmed.

ee17ed_a8ab3f4d85874d87a5c7dcf386a91889~mv2.avif

ROLEN BAGELS

3601 Riverdale Avenue, Riverdale, Bronx

​

rolenbagels.com

 

Serving Riverdale since 1993, Rolen Bagels is another neighborhood institution rooted in traditional New York bagel-making. Its bagels are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily, preserving the characteristic chewy texture and crust that made New York bagels famous. The bakery also prepares its own spreads and salads, offering classic combinations that reflect the neighborhood's Jewish food traditions. Its original Riverdale location continues to serve the community more than three decades after opening.

TRY: The everything bagel, lox sandwiches, cinnamon raisin bagel, bialys, and homemade cream cheese spreads.

KOSHER NOTE: Certified kosher by the International Kosher Council. The bakery is closed on Saturdays.

HOLIDAY NOTE: An excellent option for Shabbat preparations, Sunday brunches, and Jewish holiday gatherings. Contact the bakery regarding holiday catering and availability.

PASSOVER NOTE: No certified kosher-for-Passover bagel offerings confirmed.

BAGEL CORNER

581 West 235th Street, Riverdale, Bronx

​

bagelcorner1967.com

 

A true Bronx bagel institution, Bagel Corner traces its history to 1967. Located in Riverdale, a neighborhood with a longstanding Jewish community, the bakery continues the traditional process of making New York bagels in small batches, kettle-boiling and baking them fresh daily. The bakery emphasizes its traditional methods, using no preservatives and avoiding shortcuts. Its substantial bagels, chewy interiors, and carefully seasoned everything bagels have earned recognition among New York City's standout bagel shops.

TRY: The everything bagel with cream cheese, lox sandwiches, fresh schmears, and assorted bagels by the dozen.

KOSHER NOTE: The Riverdale location is kosher certified by the International Kosher Council.

HOLIDAY NOTE: A convenient choice for Jewish holiday breakfasts, family gatherings, and catering. Contact the bakery regarding special holiday orders and schedules.

PASSOVER NOTE: Regular bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover bagel offerings confirmed.

Staten Island

HEARTLAND BAGELS

2311 Richmond Avenue, New Springville, Staten Island

 

heartlandbagelsny.com

​​

A family-run Staten Island bakery with more than 25 years of history, Heartland Bagels is particularly noteworthy for maintaining traditional kosher baking in New Springville. Located in the Heartland Village Shopping Center, the bakery prepares fresh bagels, challah, rolls, pastries, and other baked goods. Its longstanding relationship with the community extends beyond everyday breakfasts to Jewish celebrations, religious gatherings, and family events.

TRY: The everything bagel, egg bagel, bagels with cream cheese and smoked fish, fresh challah, and traditional bakery pastries.

KOSHER NOTE: The New Springville location identifies itself as strictly kosher under rabbinical supervision. This should not be confused with the company's separate Rossville location, which does not advertise the same certification.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Particularly relevant for Jewish celebrations. The bakery offers catering for brit milah celebrations, bar and bat mitzvahs, kiddushes, and shiva gatherings. Contact the bakery for Jewish holiday specialties and ordering.

PASSOVER NOTE: Regular bagels and challah are not kosher for Passover. Any Passover-specific offerings and certification should be confirmed directly.

PizdetScanner1.jpg

BAGELS R US

4300 Amboy Road, Staten Island

​

A longstanding neighborhood bagel and deli destination on Staten Island's South Shore, Bagels R Us is known for its extensive selection of fresh bagels, flavored cream cheeses, breakfast sandwiches, and deli favorites. The family-run shop reflects the traditional New York bagel-and-deli culture, where customers stop for a quick breakfast, pick up bagels by the dozen, or order sandwiches throughout the day.

TRY: The everything bagel, egg bagel, flavored cream cheese spreads, and traditional breakfast sandwiches.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. Customers requiring kosher food should verify ingredients and preparation.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Bagels by the dozen and assorted spreads are convenient for breakfast gatherings and family entertaining.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

zcg7wmlqijwd1.jpg

POPPY SEED BAGELS & CATERING

2220 Forest Avenue, Staten Island

​

A family-owned Staten Island bagel shop, Poppy Seed Bagels & Catering combines traditional New York bagels with a contemporary breakfast and lunch menu. Located on Forest Avenue, the shop has developed a local following for its fresh bagels, generous sandwiches, and catering selections. Its menu includes both classic bagel combinations and more creative breakfast offerings.

TRY: The everything bagel with cream cheese, bagel with lox, and specialty breakfast sandwiches.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. The menu includes meat and dairy combinations that are not kosher.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Catering and bagel assortments are available for family celebrations and group gatherings. Confirm holiday ordering directly.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

PIO HOT BAGELS

655 Rossville Avenue, Woodrow, Staten Island

​

Pio Hot Bagels is a Staten Island neighborhood favorite known for traditional New York bagels served fresh and hot. Its appeal is straightforward: a well-baked crust, a chewy interior, and classic flavors that need little embellishment. The shop has developed a following among local bagel enthusiasts and is particularly appealing to visitors looking for a traditional New York bagel experience away from Manhattan's busiest tourist areas.

TRY: A hot everything bagel, sesame bagel with cream cheese, and freshly baked bagels to take home.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified.

HOLIDAY NOTE: A neighborhood option for fresh bagels and breakfast gatherings. Contact the shop for advance orders and holiday hours.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

BAGELS N' BUNS

2491 Victory Boulevard, Staten Island

​

A longstanding Staten Island neighborhood bagel shop, Bagels N' Buns opened in June 1993 and has served local residents for more than three decades. The family-owned business combines traditional New York bagels with a classic deli menu, breakfast sandwiches, and catering. Its familiar neighborhood atmosphere and extensive breakfast offerings have helped establish it as a regular stop for generations of Staten Islanders.

TRY: The everything bagel with lox, cream cheese, tomato, onion, and capers, along with classic breakfast sandwiches and mini bagel platters.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. The menu includes non-kosher meat combinations.

HOLIDAY NOTE: Bagel platters and catering options are available for family gatherings and special occasions. Contact the shop for holiday availability.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

NOT JUST BAGELS

1910 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island

​

not-just-bagels.com

 

A family-owned Staten Island institution with more than two decades of history, Not Just Bagels has an interesting story of continuity and homecoming. After originally establishing the business, the founding owners eventually stepped away before returning to operate the bakery once again. Today, they continue the family tradition of preparing bagels, pastries, and other baked goods on the premises. The shop has also received recognition from the Daily News for its bagels, making it a longstanding neighborhood favorite with a story that goes beyond breakfast.

TRY: Traditional everything and sesame bagels, lox specialties, homemade muffins, specialty cream cheese flavors, and freshly baked pastries.

KOSHER NOTE: Not confirmed as kosher certified. The menu includes non-kosher meat and dairy combinations.

HOLIDAY NOTE: The bakery offers catering for family gatherings, parties, and special occasions. Contact the shop for holiday availability and advance ordering.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels and pastries are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

TOTTENVILLE BAGELS & DELI

6959 Amboy Road, Tottenville, Staten Island

​

tbagels.com

 

Serving Staten Island for more than 20 years, Tottenville Bagels & Deli has built its reputation around fresh, hand-rolled bagels baked on the premises. Located in the southernmost part of Staten Island, the shop combines traditional New York bagel-making with a large selection of breakfast and lunch favorites. One unusual feature is its advertised 24-hour operation, including holidays, making it a destination for bagel cravings well beyond the usual breakfast hours. Alongside traditional bagels, the menu includes colorful rainbow bagels and creative combinations such as bagel burgers.

TRY: The everything bagel with cream cheese, bagel with fresh Nova lox, rainbow bagels, and specialty cream cheese spreads including scallion, maple walnut, and vegetable.

KOSHER NOTE: Not kosher certified. The menu includes non-kosher meat and dairy combinations.

HOLIDAY NOTE: The shop advertises 24-hour service, including holidays, and offers bagel assortments and catering combinations for groups. Confirm hours and ordering before visiting.

PASSOVER NOTE: Traditional bagels are not kosher for Passover. No certified Passover offerings confirmed.

​

​

Try a Bagel Baking Class with Award-Winning Baker, Midtwon, Manhattan

 

Learn new culinary skills during a fun, hands-on bagel-making class led by an award-winning baker. Discover tips and tricks for making a perfect New York–style bagel, and sit down to eat your creations.

© 2026 Jewish Food NYC. All rights reserved. Third-party trademarks, logos and images remain the property of their respective owners.

Note: To the best of my ability, I’ve checked that the places and businesses featured here are current, and I’ve personally visited many of them. But New York changes quickly. Businesses close, move, change hours and sometimes change how they take orders. Always check directly before making a special trip. 

bottom of page